My Specific Process For Generating Processing Leads From Facebook Groups
(and what you should stop doing)
Wingman Agency
The Problem: 99% of Payment Processing Agents Are Selling Wrong in Facebook Groups
Pause for a second and let that sink in. You've seen it a hundred times. Probably done it yourself. Some agent drops into a restaurant owners group, posts a slick Clover graphic with "Free Terminal" plastered across it, maybe throws in some ChatGPT copy about "zero percent processing" and "best support in the industry," then sits back waiting for the leads to pour in.
Spoiler alert: they don't.
Instead, you get crickets. Good chance only 7 people out of the 10,000 seen it. Maybe a passive-aggressive comment from an admin. Possibly a warning about self-promotion. Definitely zero actual conversations with qualified merchants. And you're left scratching your head wondering why the "free marketing strategy" everyone talks about isn't working for you.
Here's the uncomfortable truth nobody wants to say out loud: you're approaching Facebook groups like they're billboards when they're actually BNI rooms. You're megaphoning when you should be chatting. You're interrupting when you should be observing. And it's killing your conversion rate before you even get a chance to pitch.
This isn't about working harder or posting more beautifully designed Dejavoo graphics. It's about fundamentally changing how you think about group engagement. Because the agents who actually build consistent pipelines from Facebook aren't the ones with the flashiest posts—they're the ones who understand that social selling is still social, and selling requires actual human connection.
(note: we aren't going to discuss lead magnets in this writeup, that will have it's own)
The Megaphone Strategy
Promotional Graphics
Posting Clover terminals, Clover logos, generic payment processing visuals that scream "advertisement"
Generic ChatGPT Copy
That corporate-sounding nonsense everyone can spot from a mile away. "Are you tired of high processing fees?"
"Comment YES Below"
The cringe-inducing call-to-action that makes you look like a multi-level marketer hawking essential oils. This does work for some offers, just not payments.
Link Drops
Throwing your scheduling link or website into comments like you're doing anyone a favor. News flash, nobody is going to book a time.
Let's call this what it is: the Megaphone Strategy. You're standing in the middle of a digital plaza, screaming your pitch at anyone within earshot, hoping someone, anyone, will stop and listen. It's the online equivalent of being that guy at a networking event who immediately shoves a business card in your face before asking your name.
Think about it in terms you already understand. When you're door knocking (and I know most of you are knocking daily), you don't stand in the middle of the main street and start spewing out your terminal/rates/best support pitch. You walk INTO the business and strike up a conversation. You comment on something real—the line out the door, the new sign, the busy season they're clearly in the middle of. You build a micro-rapport before you even mention what you do.
But online? Everyone forgets this basic principle. They see a Facebook group as a free advertising platform instead of what it actually is: a room full of your perfect audience who joined to network, learn, and connect with other business owners. Not to be sold to by the fiftieth ISO agent this week.

The irony? Admin warnings about self-promotion are basically your market telling you that your approach isn't working. When multiple people are getting kicked out for the same behavior, maybe it's time to try something different.
Why the Megaphone Strategy Fails
What Business Owners Want
They joined groups to learn from peers, discover best practices, and network with other people running similar businesses. They want community, not pitches.
What They Get Instead
  • Endless promotional posts
  • Generic sales copy
  • Agents who all sound identical
  • Zero actual value or insight
  • Interruptions to real conversations
Let's break down the psychology here because this is where amateurs and operators split paths. When someone joins a "Restaurant Owners Network" or "Independent Retailers Forum," they're not thinking "I hope some payment processors find me here." They're thinking "I need advice on hiring" or "How are other owners handling this supply chain issue?" or "Check out this cool thing I did".
Group feeds are noisy as hell. Every other post is someone asking a question, sharing a win, or venting about a challenge. Your promotional post—no matter how well-designed—is just noise competing with actual valuable content. And here's the kicker: Facebook's algorithm knows this. Posts that generate engagement (comments, shares, meaningful interaction) get MORE visibility. When they see a post crushing it, it gets shown to more people. This is how viral happens. Posts that get ignored or hidden get buried, big time. Like certain files about powerful people doing bad things.
When you drop a Clover graphic, you're signaling to everyone in that group that you don't understand the space you're in. You look exactly like every other ISO agent who joined five minutes ago and immediately started spamming. You're not differentiated. You're not memorable. You're wallpaper.

( I own 30+ SMB groups, and I just kick you out lol ).
Business owners develop banner blindness to promotional content faster than you'd think. They scroll past it without even registering what it says. Meanwhile, the agents who are actually generating leads from these groups? They're invisible in the feed. You don't see their promotional posts because they're not making promotional posts. They're in the comments, building relationships one conversation at a time.
This is what separates people who "tried Facebook groups and they didn't work" from people who consistently generate qualified conversations every single week. It's not about the group. It's about the approach.
The Right Way: Digital Door Knocking
Yes, I coined the phrase a couple years ago :)
Here's the reframe that changes everything for you going forward: Facebook groups aren't advertising platforms. They're BNI rooms. And if you already know how to door knock effectively, you already have the exact skillset you need, you're just applying it in the wrong format. Instead of working on your pitch, you need to work on your social skills and writing ability (plus a little bit of "courage" to post something lol.
Think about your best door knocking interactions. What made them work? You didn't walk up to a busy restaurant during lunch rush, interrupt the owner taking orders, and launch into a pitch about interchange rates. That's insane. Nobody does that (well, nobody good does that).
Instead, you observed. You waited for the right moment. You commented on something happening in their business—"Man, you guys are slammed today, that's awesome" or "I saw the new sign out front, looks great." You built a tiny bit of rapport, got them talking, let them share something about their business. Then, and only then, did you transition into what you do and how you might help.
Online is exactly the same process. The only difference is instead of physically walking into their space, you're entering a digital conversation. But the principles don't change: observe, comment naturally, build rapport, then transition. The problem is most agents skip straight to the transition part because they think "online is different." It's not.
1
Enter Their Space
Join groups where your ICP actually hangs out
2
Observe
Watch what they post, what problems they share, what they celebrate
3
Comment Naturally
Add value or acknowledge what they shared like a real person would
4
Build Rapport
Let them respond, engage back once or twice
5
Pivot
Move the conversation to DMs where the real sales process begins
This approach works because you're not interrupting,you're participating. You're not selling. You're connecting. And by the time you move to DMs, you've already established that you're not just another spammy agent. You're someone who actually paid attention to their business and had something relevant to say.
The Comment Threading Framework
Alright, let's get tactical. This isn't theory, this is the exact process you should be running daily if you're serious about building pipeline from Facebook groups (or in your feed). This framework works because it mirrors how real relationships form, just compressed into a digital environment.
01
Identify ICP Posts
Look for signals that indicate growth, change, or pain points in businesses that match your ideal customer profile
02
Comment Naturally
Respond like a human, not a salesperson. Acknowledge what they shared without pitching anything
03
Engage Back and Forth
Let them respond to your comment, then reply once more. Build a micro-conversation publicly
04
Leave It One Short
Don't pitch publicly. Don't transition in the comments. Stop the thread while it's still warm
05
DM to Continue
Move to private messages with a natural reason to continue the conversation. Start this conversation WITH THE SAME THING YOU WERE DISCUSSING IN THE GROUP!
What to Look For in Step 1
You're scanning group feeds for specific types of posts that signal opportunity. Don't just scroll randomly. You're looking for posts about growth (we just opened a second location), hiring (looking for servers for busy season), expansion (upgrading our POS system), busy seasons (this weekend was absolutely insane), or complaints about software (our current system keeps crashing during checkout). These are all natural openings.
When you find a post like "Just hired three new employees to handle the summer rush," that's not a cue to drop a comment about payment processing. That's a cue to acknowledge their growth: "This season must've been insane for you. Summer rush is no joke in the restaurant business." That's it. That's the comment.
The magic happens when they respond. They'll usually add context—"Yeah, we're up 40% from last year, barely keeping up"—and now you've got a real thread going. You respond once more: "40% is huge, congrats. That's the kind of growth that breaks systems if you're not careful." Still no pitch. You're just having a conversation like a normal human.
Then you leave it. Don't keep going. Don't add "by the way, I work in payment processing." Just let that comment sit there. A few hours later, or the next day, you slide into their DMs: "Hey man, saw your post about the growth this season. That's killer. Out of curiosity, what are you using to handle payments right now?" And now it feels natural because you already have context from the public thread.

Pro tip: The "leave it one short" rule is critical. You want them to feel like the conversation got interrupted naturally, not concluded. That makes the DM transition feel like you're picking up where you left off, not cold messaging them.
DM Transition Example
Your Original Approach
"Hey seen you run a landscaping company. I run a payment processing company. You taking payments through QuickBooks or Jobber?"
This is actually pretty good—it's direct, assumes they're already processing (doesn't insult their intelligence), and creates a natural opening. But let's refine it for maximum impact.
Improved Version
"Hey man, saw your post about tripling this season. Unreal growth. Out of curiosity, has anything broke growing that fast?"
Notice the difference? You're referencing the specific context from the group thread, acknowledging their win, then transitioning naturally into the question. In time (usually 4-5 messages), this will transition into something you can use.
Why This Refined Approach Works Better
First, it shows you actually read their post and remember the details. Most agents send generic DMs that could go to anyone. "Saw your post about tripling this season" proves you're paying attention to their specific situation, not just spamming everyone in the group.
Second, "unreal growth" is a genuine acknowledgment that hits different than a robotic "congratulations." It sounds like how one business person talks to another, not how a salesperson talks to a prospect. Word choice matters more than people think.
You're not demanding information, you're genuinely curious. It lowers their guard because it doesn't feel like a setup for a pitch (even though it obviously is).
1
Context Reference
"Saw your post about tripling"
2
Genuine Acknowledgment
"Unreal growth"
3
Curiosity Frame
"Out of curiosity"
4
Specific Question
"has anything broke growing that fast?"
The beautiful thing about this formula is it works across industries and situations. Just swap in the specific detail from their post. "Saw your post about opening the second location" or "Saw your post about the hiring challenges" or "Saw your post about upgrading your POS." Then acknowledge, soften with curiosity, and ask the question. It's repeatable without being formulaic because the context changes every time.
Execution Metrics
You know what separates agents who consistently generate pipeline from agents who "tried it for a week and it didn't work"? →Structure. This isn't about motivation or inspiration, it's about treating Facebook groups like a daily prospecting channel with measurable activity metrics, just like you would with door knocking or cold calling.
Here's your daily activity benchmark. This should be non-negotiable if you're actually serious about building a pipeline through group engagement. Not aspirational numbers you'll do "when you have time"—actual daily discipline.
20
Meaningful Comments
Not "great post" garbage. Real comments on ICP posts that show you read and understood what they shared
5
Active Threads
Comments that generate back-and-forth dialogue. If nobody responds, the comment wasn't meaningful enough
3
DM Transitions
Natural moves from public threads to private conversations where actual sales discussions happen
1
Statement Deal
Every few days, one conversation should progress far enough to request a merchant statement for review
Let's be real about what this takes time-wise. Twenty meaningful comments sounds like a lot, but if you're in the right groups with active feeds, you can knock this out in 30-45 minutes. You're not writing essays, you're leaving 1-2 sentence observations that add value or acknowledge what someone shared. Scroll, identify ICP (ideal client profile) posts, comment naturally, move on.

If you can swing it, humor does well (this is 75% of my style on Facebook personally).
Five threads means five of those comments actually generated responses. If you're not hitting this, your comments aren't strong enough or you're commenting on dead posts. Focus on recent posts (within the last few hours) where the original poster is likely still active and will see your comment quickly.
Three DM transitions is your bridge from activity to pipeline. Not everyone will respond to your DMs, so you need volume here. Some will ignore you, some will say "not interested right now," but a percentage will engage. That's the game. Just like door knocking. You're building a consistent flow of new conversations every single day.
In a year, you'll have 10+ people a week just showing up in your inbox asking for more information on how to switch or save.
One booked call or lead every few days is your conversion metric in the beginning, don't get discouraged.. This means the conversation went well enough that they're willing to share their current processing statement for you to review, jump on a call, take a look at your offer page (hopefully you have this and not a 10 page website to send them). That's a qualified lead. Not everyone converts, but if you're generating 4-5 leads per week from group activity alone, you're building a serious pipeline.

Track these metrics somewhere—notes app, spreadsheet, CRM, doesn't matter. What gets measured gets managed. You should know your conversion rate from comments to threads, threads to DMs, DMs to statement requests. If you need a CRM that helps automate followups and stuff, I build that for agents (go to https://wingmanagency.co)
Mistakes Agents Make
Let's call out the specific behaviors that tank your credibility and kill any chance of building real pipeline from groups. If you're doing any of these, stop immediately. Seriously. These are the tells that identify you as an amateur who doesn't understand the space they're posting in.
1
Pitching Publicly
Never, ever transition to your offer in the group comments. The second you mention payment processing, surcharging, or ask for a statement publicly, you've blown it. That conversation dies and everyone watching knows you were never actually interested in their business…you were just "setting up" a pitch. All sales conversations happen in DMs, period (if someone asks you publicly, share some of the offer and then ask if you can send a quick message)
2
Over-Explaining Things
Stop trying to educate entire groups about interchange optimization, dual pricing, or how surcharging compliance works. Nobody asked, nobody cares in that format, and you sound like you're reading from a script. Save the technical breakdown for one-on-one conversations with people who've already expressed interest.
3
Posting Links
Your calendar link, website, "free savings analysis" landing page….nobody clicks these in group comments. They're spam signals that get you flagged by admins and scrolled past by members. Links come way later in the sales process, after trust is established or by engaging, and having people view your profile (where your lead link should be. More on this on last slide).
4
Trying to "Educate" the Group
Those long-form posts about "5 things restaurant owners should know about credit card processing" or "The truth about interchange fees"? They're thinly veiled marketing that everyone sees through. If you want to provide value, do it in response to specific questions people actually ask, not as standalone promotional content. Danny the Sub Shop owner didn't wake up curious about interchange.
5
Sounding Like Marketing Copy
If your comments sound like they came from ChatGPT or a corporate social media guidebook, you've already lost. "I'd love to help you optimize your payment processing solutions" makes you sound like a bot. Talk like a human. Use some slang or be colloquial. Be conversational. Real people don't speak in LinkedIn-ese.
Here's antoher truth you already know: business owners can smell sales desperation from a mile away. When you make any of these mistakes, you're broadcasting that you need deals more than you care about their business. That dynamic kills sales before they start.
The agents who actually win in groups are the ones who look like regular members, not salespeople. Their comments blend in because they're genuinely participating in the community. You shouldn't be able to tell they're payment processors from their comment history. That's the whole point. They're building relationships first, generating opportunities second.
Trojan Horse Method stuff
If an admin has ever warned you about self-promotion or kicked you from a group, you made one of these mistakes. Take that as feedback, not as "groups don't work" or "admins are too strict." You got caught because your approach was too obvious. Refine your technique and you'll never trigger those flags again. Operate like Jason Bourne, but the payments version haha.
Facebook Groups Are Networking Rooms, Not Billboards
Build Real Relationships
Nobody scrolls Facebook hoping a payment processor finds them. They're there to connect with peers, learn from others, and participate in community. If you're treating groups like advertising platforms, you're fundamentally misunderstanding the medium. Show up like a member, not a marketer.
Master Conversation Skills
Your ability to read a post, add genuine value in comments, and naturally transition to DMs matters infinitely more than your Canva skills or how many emojis you use. If you can't build rapport digitally, you're leaving money on the table. This is selling, just in a different format.
If you're serious about building a portfolio that actually generates consistent residual income, you need to accept that modern lead generation isn't about who has the flashiest graphics or most aggressive posting schedule. It's about who can have real conversations with business owners where they're already spending time. Facebook groups are one of those places, but only if you approach them correctly.
The Megaphone Strategy is dead. It's been dead for years, but agents keep trying it because it feels like you're doing something. Posting graphics, dropping links, commenting "DM me for details"—that's all activity theater. It looks like work but generates nothing because business owners have trained themselves to ignore it completely.
The Comment Threading Framework works because it's based on how humans actually form business relationships: attention, relevance, rapport, then transition. You're just compressing the timeline and using digital tools to scale what used to require physically showing up places. Door knocking taught you the principles; groups are just a different door to knock on.
So here's your choice: keep doing what 99% of agents do and wonder why groups "don't work," or commit to the framework, track your metrics, refine your approach, and start building real pipeline from digital networking. The agents who win aren't the ones with the most group memberships, they're the ones who actually understand how to engage once they're inside.
Stop treating Facebook groups like billboards. Start treating them like BNI rooms. That shift alone will change your entire approach and, more importantly, your results.
Your Profile: The Final Piece of the Puzzle
You've mastered digital door-knocking, perfected your comment threading, and transitioned seamlessly into DMs. You're building genuine relationships and generating interest. But what happens when those hundreds, or even thousands, of potential clients inevitably check out your Facebook profile? Is it a dead end, or a conversion machine?
All that hard work building rapport can be wasted if your profile isn't optimized to capture leads. Think of your profile as your digital storefront – it needs to guide interested visitors toward the next step. Without a clear "profile funnel" and a compelling lead-converting sales page, you're leaving countless opportunities on the table. It's the critical link between social engagement and actually filling your pipeline.
This isn't about looking busy; it's about being effective. A well-designed profile funnel acts as an automated assistant, warmly welcoming curious prospects and guiding them to express their interest, whether through a clear call to action, a valuable lead magnet, or a direct contact form.
It’s how you convert casual profile viewers into active leads, ensuring every moment you spend networking online translates into real potential.
If you don't have a profile funnel setup, send me a message on Facebook. They're inexpensive and help you generate more leads over time.
Need marketing, automated crm, ai or lead gen for merchant services?